top of page
Back To Top
The outside of our beautiful bakery
The inside of our bake shop
A view of all our delectable baked goods
We have a counter cooler for slices of our cheesecakes and pies

We deliver to The Villages and immediate surrounding areas. Our cookies make the perfect gift for any cookie monster and for any occasion. Who in your life wouldn't love cookies baked with love, from scratch and hand-stirred? They taste amazing with coffee, tea, or a tall, cold glass of milk. They are also perfect for parties, company or even yourself; when you want to feel like a kid again! They are great for those times when you need a dessert or a gift , but are short on time.

When placing an order, please allow for 48 hrs notice, if possible.

 

Special orders take time. Thank you.

Welcome To
Red Rooster Cookie Jar
In historic Lady Lake, FL

Cookie of the Week

Red velvet.heic

Experience the irresistible allure of our

RED VELVET cookies, crafted with rich Dutch-process cocoa and indulgent cream cheese chips. Each creamy bite delivers a perfect balance of sweetness and decadence, making these cookies an essential treat. Once you try them, you’ll find yourself coming back for more. They will be available starting on 2/2 in our bake shop. Remember once they are sold out they are gone until next year!

OUR SECRET RECIPE

FRESH INGREDIENTS

Our first ingredient is always love, and we also use the freshest ingredients from local businesses and farmers. This recipe makes them the best treats you will ever put in your mouth. we guarantee it. 

FRIENDLY SERVICE

Our staff is 100% committed to making your experience with us the absolute best it can be.

We promise you will become a customer for life. We want you feel like you are visiting family when you walk through our door.

Locally Owned

LOCALLY OWNED

We are residents of the Villages and your community.

We’re not just a cookie shop; we’re your neighbors.

Locally owned and operated since 2018.

Local Delivery

OUR CUSTOMERS LOVE US

You did an amazing job delivering the cookies to my dad. Thank you so much! Your website was easy to navigate and place the order. I received a notice they had been delivered but my dad had not yet received them, but when I reached out AFTER HOURS I received a reply and a follow up the next morning.

 

That's GREAT service.

 

They told me the cookies are big and fat and delicious. That's outstanding. 
Have a wonderful holiday season. 

Kim M.

Reviews

"These cookies are so delicious! Each one is packed with flavor and the variety is mouthwatering! I ordered 3 dozen variety for my mom’s birthday and she was so delighted. Delivery was quick and easy and I was able to get them same day in The Villages!  We will absolutely be ordering again!"

Emily Bennett (Facebook)

Reviews

"Thanks so much for 1-the excellent flavors; 2-the excellent service; 3-the close proximity; and 4-the friendly interactions on the phone and in person when picking up the order."

Jake Nemergut

Guidetoflorida.com

Reviews

"What a delight to receive a box of Red Rooster cookies in the mail as a cheerful gift for the holidays! We especially enjoyed the apple, salted caramel, and snickerdoodle cookies. The packaging was perfect too as cookies were individually wrapped and good for grabbing on the go. I would be happy to give or receive these cookies anytime of the year. Yum 😋"

Esta Liederman

(Facebook)

MORE PLACES TO FIND US

Like Us On Facebook And Follow Us On Instagram

Browns Farms And Country Store

13940 N. US-301, Oxford, FL

Our cheesecake - Francesco's Ristorante & Stone Fire Pizza

16770 US-441, Summerfield, FL  34491

Pasta Faire

10401 US, Belleview, FL 34420

The Standard Christian Library Coffee Lounge

1552 Bella Cruz Drive, The Villages, FL  32159

To The Moon And Back Frozen Treats

1692 Highway 68 N. STE B,  Oak Ridge, NC 27310

189 Hickory Tree Road,  Winston Salem, NC 27107

Our 1yr Birthday Party on November 9th, 2024

Winners of our raffle!

Hello to the Red Rooster TEAM!

 

My husband, Doug and I deemed ourselves taste testers of BOTH of your cinnamon rolls this morning!

Have we ever been disappointed with ANYTHING baked by y'all!?

NO WAY!!

Thank you for being willing to reserve our cinnamon rolls, too!

Do you think we were able to walk away with just cinnamon rolls?

AGAIN

NO WAY!

My husband loves your Mango Clouds!

A couple other treats found their way into our red bag of goodies ... biscotti and the traditional chocolate chippers that put y'all on the road to BAKING BLISS/SUCCESS!

 

We will be back!

Please give Miss Kathy (I hope that is how she spells her lovely name!) 

ALL OUR GRATITUDE for being so welcoming and kind to us!

I don't have to tell you that she is the perfect "front gal" for the bakery!

A class act!

So efficient, knowledgeable, generous, and sweet!

 

One more comment ... y'all go the extra mile with your darling packaging/presentation, too!

 

With loving thanks,

Joy and Doug Moser

Buena Vista, CO (snowbirds in TV!)

bottom of page